Clayton, Indiana Homes for Sale

Active

1 / 18

$199,900

1929 E Us HWY 40

3 bd2 ba1,120 sqft

Single Family·Built 1966·F.C. Tucker Company

View Listing

Pending

1 / 25

$239,000

4886 N Ohio Street

3 bd2 ba1,515 sqft

Single Family·Built 1971·eXp Realty, LLC

View Listing

Pending

1 / 42

$319,900

517 Martha Eunice Lane

3 bd2 ba1,421 sqft

Single Family·Built 1998·RE/MAX Centerstone

View Listing

Active

1 / 24

$304,999

10255 Hodge Road

4 bd2 ba1,988 sqft

Single Family·Built 1970·Greene Realty, LLC

View Listing

Active

1 / 50

$392,900

5631 Bluewing Creek Lane

4 bd3 ba1,961 sqft

Single Family·Built 2026·DRH Realty of Indiana, LLC

View Listing

Active

1 / 77

$426,100

3813 Donaldson Crk Drive

5 bd3 ba2,600 sqft

Single Family·Built 2026·DRH Realty of Indiana, LLC

View Listing

Active

1 / 57

$405,525

3850 Donaldson Creek Drive

4 bd3 ba2,346 sqft

Single Family·Built 2026·DRH Realty of Indiana, LLC

View Listing

Pending

1 / 77

$450,000

4242 Lakewood Court

4 bd3 ba3,992 sqft

Single Family·Built 1963·@properties

View Listing

Pending

1 / 26

$369,900

100d

3740 Marlowe Creek Drive

4 bd2 ba1,771 sqft

Single Family·Built 2025·DRH Realty of Indiana, LLC

View Listing

Pending

1 / 27

$409,900

89d

3884 Donaldson Creek Court

4 bd3 ba2,346 sqft

Single Family·Built 2025·DRH Realty of Indiana, LLC

View Listing

Pending

1 / 53

$433,000

42d

5413 S County Road 0

3 bd2 ba1,622 sqft

Single Family·Built 1886·eXp Realty, LLC

View Listing

Active

1 / 31

$349,999

63d

2510 Oak Drive

3 bd2 ba1,771 sqft

Single Family·Built 2006·Keller Williams Indy Metro NE

View Listing

Homes for Sale in Clayton, IN

Clayton Market Overview

By Property Type

Explore Clayton, IN