Menasha Wi Rentals

1073 Stillmeadow Lane #2, Menasha, WI 54952

1 / 20

$1,299/mo

Available Now

1073 Stillmeadow Lane #2

2 bd1 ba— sqft

Single Family·via Wiechmann·Cats allowed, Dogs allowed

View Listing

1 / 11

$999/mo

Available Now

60/62 Tayco Street - 60

2 bd1 ba— sqft

Multi-Family·via Blue Frog Property Management·N/A

View Listing

1 / 8

$950/mo

Available Now

1273 Manitowoc Road - 3

2 bd1 ba— sqft

Single Family·via Titan Property Management, LLC·N/A

View Listing

1 / 11

$899/mo

Available Now

844 3rd Street - 1/2

2 bd1 ba— sqft

Multi-Family·via Blue Frog Property Management·N/A

View Listing

1 / 16

$2,400/mo

Available Now

1656 Northridge Court

4 bd2 ba— sqft

Single Family·via Titan Property Management, LLC·N/A

View Listing

1 / 22

$1,049/mo

Available Now

535 Schindler Place 7

1 bd1 ba950 sqft

Apartment·via RS Portal Property Management·Cats allowed, Small dogs allowed

View Listing

1 / 7

$525/mo

Available Now

400 1/2 Walnut Street

1 bd1 ba— sqft

Multi-Family·via Titan Property Management, LLC·Pets allowed

View Listing

1 / 10

$909/mo

Available Now

200 Olde Pulley Lane Apt P

1 bd1 ba650 sqft

Single Family·via RS Portal Property Management·Cats allowed, Dogs allowed

View Listing

1 / 7

$1,169/mo

Available Now

315 Tyler 1

2 bd1 ba1,006 sqft

Apartment·via RS Portal Property Management·Cats allowed, Dogs not allowed

View Listing

1 / 10

$909/mo

Available Now

228 Olde Pulley Lane Apt G

1 bd1 ba650 sqft

Single Family·via RS Portal Property Management·Cats allowed, Dogs allowed

View Listing

1 / 4

$1,019/mo

Available May 1

1330 Lucerne Drive 9

1 bd1 ba990 sqft

Apartment·via RS Portal Property Management·N/A

View Listing

1 / 19

$999/mo

Available Now

515 Schindler Place 9

1 bd1 ba950 sqft

Apartment·via RS Portal Property Management·Cats allowed, Small dogs allowed

View Listing

Rental Market Analysis — Menasha, WI

Fizbo has collected 44 rental listings in Menasha, WI. Among these, monthly rents range from $525 to $2,400, with an average of $1,106/mo and a median of $1,049/mo. 39 units are available for immediate move-in, and 5 more become available within the next 30 days.

These properties range from 1 to 4 bedrooms and 1 to 2 bathrooms, averaging 1.8 beds / 1.1 baths. Living space averages 977 sqft (range: 650–1,150 sqft). Rent scales with size: 0-bedroom units average $599/mo (1 listing), 1-bedroom units average $969/mo (17 listings), 2-bedroom units average $1,128/mo (17 listings), 3-bedroom units average $1,288/mo (7 listings), 4+-bedroom units average $2,400/mo (1 listing).

These listings are primarily composed of Apartments (73%), Single Familys (18%) and Multi-Familys (9%). Security deposits average $760, ranging from $500 to $2,400.

32 of 44 listings (73%) are pet-friendly. Properties are managed by 5 property management companies, led by RS Portal Property Management (24 listings).

Our AI photo analysis across these listing images reveals common finishes and features. The most prevalent countertop material is Laminate Countertops (found in 18% of listings). Carpet is the most common flooring (23%). Refrigerator appliances appear in 77% of units. The most common architectural style is Traditional (34% of listings, avg $1,097/mo). Properties rated “Updated” rent for an average of $1,071/mo, compared to $999/mo for “Dated” units — a $72/mo premium for higher-quality finishes.

Menasha Rentals

Avg Rent by Bedroom

Property Types

Lease Terms

Property Managers

Availability

Popular Features

AI Photo Analysis · Price by Finish

Countertops

Flooring

Cabinets

Appliances

Exterior

Outdoor

Garage

Home Style

Condition & Price

Rental Market Analysis — Menasha, WI