Middletown In Rentals

2311 Grand Avenue,, Middletown, OH 45044

1 / 20

$1,125/mo

Available Now

2311 Grand Avenue

2 bd1.5 ba1,542 sqft

Single Family·via Bbrents·Cats allowed, Dogs allowed

View Listing

1 / 26

$4,995/mo

Available Now

2501 Elmo PL

3 bd1 ba2,044 sqft

Single Family·via Halfrealty·Cats allowed, Dogs allowed

View Listing

2000 Minnesota Ave., Middletown, OH 45044

1 / 59

$4,500/mo

Available Now

2000 Minnesota Ave.

3 bd2 ba1,500 sqft

Single Family·via Halfrealty·Cats allowed, Dogs allowed

View Listing

1007 Elwood Street, , Middletown, OH 45042

1 / 23

$1,295/mo

Available Now

1007 Elwood Street

3 bd1.5 ba1,128 sqft

Single Family·via Bbrents·Cats allowed, Dogs allowed

View Listing

1 / 18

$750/mo

Available Now

4534 Bonita Drive - 6

1 bd1 ba— sqft

Apartment·via Agora's Maxxed Out Realty·Pets allowed

View Listing

1 / 24

$1,225/mo

Available Now

2107 Queen Avenue

3 bd1.5 ba1,165 sqft

Single Family·via Bbrents·Cats allowed, Dogs allowed

View Listing

1 / 10

$825/mo

Available Now

2319 Tytus Avenue - 1

2 bd1 ba675 sqft

Single Family·via Agora's Maxxed Out Realty·Pets allowed

View Listing

1 / 21

$2,400/mo

Available Now

2000 Pearl Street - Unit A

2 bd1 ba— sqft

Apartment·via Halfrealty·Cats not allowed, Dogs not allowed

View Listing

1 / 21

$825/mo

Available Now

2319 Tytus Avenue - 2

2 bd1 ba675 sqft

Single Family·via Agora's Maxxed Out Realty·Pets allowed

View Listing

1 / 8

$695/mo

Available Now

1618 - 1620 Taylor Avenue - 1620 Taylor

1 bd1 ba468 sqft

Multi-Family·via Bbrents·Cats allowed, Small dogs allowed

View Listing

1 / 16

$2,995/mo

Available Now

3511 Lefferson Road

2 bd1 ba999 sqft

Multi-Family·via Halfrealty·Cats not allowed, Dogs not allowed

View Listing

1 / 11

$800/mo

Available Now

1600 1st Avenue - 1602

0 bd0 ba950 sqft

Single Family·via Kenship Real Estate Services LLC·N/A

View Listing

Rental Market Analysis — Middletown, RI

Fizbo has collected 37 rental listings in Middletown, RI. Among these, monthly rents range from $695 to $9,500, with an average of $3,002/mo and a median of $2,495/mo. 35 units are available for immediate move-in, and 2 more become available within the next 30 days.

These properties range from 1 to 5 bedrooms and 1 to 3 bathrooms, averaging 2.7 beds / 1.4 baths. Living space averages 1,385 sqft (range: 468–5,340 sqft). Rent scales with size: 0-bedroom units average $800/mo (1 listing), 1-bedroom units average $759/mo (5 listings), 2-bedroom units average $2,302/mo (13 listings), 3-bedroom units average $2,731/mo (9 listings), 4+-bedroom units average $5,774/mo (9 listings).

These listings are primarily composed of Single Familys (62%), Apartments (24%) and Multi-Familys (14%). Security deposits average $3,010, ranging from $695 to $9,500. Properties were built between 1897 and 2023, with an average construction year of 1986.

35 of 37 listings (95%) are pet-friendly. Properties are managed by 7 property management companies, led by Halfrealty (18 listings).

Our AI photo analysis across these listing images reveals common finishes and features. The most prevalent countertop material is Laminate Countertops (found in 16% of listings, -39% vs. average rent). Hardwood Flooring is the most common flooring (19%). White Appliances appliances appear in 16% of units. The most common architectural style is Traditional (16% of listings, avg $1,298/mo). Properties rated “Updated” rent for an average of $2,835/mo, compared to $890/mo for “Average” units — a $1,945/mo premium for higher-quality finishes.

Middletown Rentals

Avg Rent by Bedroom

Property Types

Lease Terms

Property Managers

Availability

Popular Features

AI Photo Analysis · Price by Finish

Countertops

Flooring

Cabinets

Appliances

Exterior

Outdoor

Home Style

Condition & Price

Rental Market Analysis — Middletown, RI