Rentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For Rent
Rentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For Rent
Rentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For Rent
Rentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For Rent
Rentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For Rent
Rentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For Rent
Rentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For Rent
Rentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For Rent
Rentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For Rent
Rentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For Rent
Rentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For Rent
Rentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For Rent
Rentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For Rent
Rentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For Rent
Rentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For Rent
Rentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For Rent
Rentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For Rent
Rentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For Rent
Rentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For Rent
Rentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For RentRentals New Holstein · WI Homes For Rent
Fizbo
Compare ↔
← Back to Fizbo

New Holstein Rentals

14Rentals
$910Avg/Mo
$749Low
$1,110High
13Now
2129 Randolph Ave #106, New Holstein, WI 53061
1 / 18
$879/mo
Available Now

2129 Randolph Ave #106

1 bd1 ba565 sqft
Single Family·via Wiechmann·Cats allowed, Small dogs allowed
View Listing
2129 Randolph Ave. #208, New Holstein, WI 53061
1 / 27
$849/mo
Available Now

2129 Randolph Ave. #208

1 bd1 ba565 sqft
Single Family·via Wiechmann·Cats allowed, Small dogs allowed
View Listing
1709 Jefferson St. #8, New Holstein, WI 53061
1 / 35
$859/mo
Available Now

1709 Jefferson St. #8

1 bd1 ba849 sqft
Single Family·via Wiechmann·Cats allowed, Small dogs allowed
View Listing
2129 Randolph Ave. #206, New Holstein, WI 53061
1 / 24
$849/mo
Available Now

2129 Randolph Ave. #206

1 bd1 ba565 sqft
Single Family·via Wiechmann·Cats allowed, Small dogs allowed
View Listing
1 / 26
$959/mo
Available Now

1709 Jefferson St. #1

2 bd1 ba825 sqft
Single Family·via Wiechmann·Cats allowed, Small dogs allowed
View Listing
1 / 49
$1,110/mo
Available Now

1709 Jefferson St. #2

3 bd1 ba1,059 sqft
Single Family·via Wiechmann·Cats allowed, Small dogs allowed
View Listing
1 / 22
$959/mo
Available Now

1709 Jefferson St. #4

2 bd1 ba— sqft
Single Family·via Wiechmann·Cats allowed, Small dogs allowed
View Listing
1 / 36
$959/mo
Available Now

1709 Jefferson St. #6

2 bd1 ba825 sqft
Single Family·via Wiechmann·Cats allowed, Small dogs allowed
View Listing
1 / 28
$749/mo
Available Now

2129 Randolph Ave. #102

— bd1 ba350 sqft
Apartment·via Wiechmann·Cats allowed, Small dogs allowed
View Listing
1 / 10
$875/mo
Available Now

1806 Jackson St - 4

2 bd1 ba800 sqft
Apartment·via Titan Property Management, LLC·Pets allowed
View Listing
1 / 12
$959/mo
Available Now

1709 Jefferson St. #7

2 bd1 ba— sqft
Single Family·via Wiechmann·Cats allowed, Small dogs allowed
View Listing
1 / 7
$895/mo
Available Now

2018 Wisconsin Avenue - 2

2 bd1 ba— sqft
Multi-Family·via Titan Property Management, LLC·N/A
View Listing
$895
Median Rent
13
Pet Friendly
$953
Avg Deposit
697
Avg Sqft
$799–$1,160
Deposit Range
350–1,059
Sqft Range
—
Year Built
—
Avg Year

Avg Rent by Bedroom

1 bd
$863(5)
2 bd
$938(7)
3 bd
$1,110(1)

Property Types

Single Family
1071%
Apartment
321%
Multi-Family
17%

Lease Terms

Rent: $959 | Application Fee: $25 | Security Deposit: $1,009 | Available Now
429%
Rent: $849 | Application Fee: $25 | Security Deposit: $899 | Available Now
214%
Not specified
214%
Rent: $879 | Application Fee: $25 | Security Deposit: $929 | Available 5/1/26
17%
Rent: $1,110 | Application Fee: $25 | Security Deposit: $1,160 | Available Now
17%
Rent: $879 | Application Fee: $25 | Security Deposit: $929 | Available 4/1/26
17%
Rent: $749 | Application Fee: $25 | Security Deposit: $799 | Available Now
17%
Rent: $959 | Application Fee: $25 | Security Deposit: $1,009 | Available 4/1/26
17%
Rent: $859 | Application Fee: $25 | Security Deposit: $909 | Available Now
17%

Property Managers

Wiechmann
1286%
Titan Property Management, LLC
214%

Availability

Available Now
1393%
Within 30 Days
17%
30+ Days Out
00%

Popular Features

On-Site Coin-Operated Laundry12Pet-Friendly12Off-Street Parking12blinds12Quiet Neighborhood12Close to Park12Assigned Tenant Parking12Professionally Managed12

AI Photo Analysis · Price by Finish

Average rent correlated with finishes detected in listing photos

Countertops

Laminate Countertops
$931+2%
11 (79%)

Flooring

Carpet
$931+2%
11 (79%)
Tile Flooring
$928+2%
10 (71%)
Brown
$942+4%
8 (57%)
Polished Concrete
$923+1%
7 (50%)
Gray
$952+5%
4 (29%)
Blue
$859-6%
3 (21%)

Cabinets

Traditional
$931+2%
9 (64%)
Shaker Cabinets
$954+5%
5 (36%)
Dark Wood Cabinets
$934+3%
4 (29%)
Flat Panel Cabinets
$1,009+11%
3 (21%)
Light Wood Cabinets
$904-1%
2 (14%)
Open Shelving
$849-7%
2 (14%)

Appliances

Refrigerator
$914
12 (86%)
White Appliances
$931+2%
11 (79%)
Dishwasher
$989+9%
5 (36%)
Electric Range
$899-1%
3 (21%)

Exterior

Brick Exterior
$968+6%
6 (43%)
Paved
$904-1%
4 (29%)
Paved Parking Lot
$973+7%
3 (21%)
Shingle
$926+2%
3 (21%)
Asphalt Parking Lot
$926+2%
3 (21%)
Concrete Walkway
$959+5%
2 (14%)

Outdoor

Mature Trees
$928+2%
8 (57%)
Balconies
$969+6%
5 (36%)
Green Lawn
$972+7%
4 (29%)
Lawn
$886-3%
3 (21%)
Balcony
$854-6%
2 (14%)
Covered Entrance
$904-1%
2 (14%)

Garage

Carport
$966+6%
7 (50%)

Home Style

Traditional$931/mo
11 (79%)

Condition & Price

Average
$931/mo
11 (79%)

Rental Market Analysis — New Holstein, WI

Fizbo has collected 14 rental listings in New Holstein, WI. Among these, monthly rents range from $749 to $1,110, with an average of $910/mo and a median of $895/mo. 13 units are available for immediate move-in, and 1 more becomes available within the next 30 days.

These properties range from 1 to 3 bedrooms and 1 to 1 bathroom, averaging 1.7 beds / 1 bath. Living space averages 697 sqft (range: 350–1,059 sqft). Rent scales with size: 1-bedroom units average $863/mo (5 listings), 2-bedroom units average $938/mo (7 listings), 3-bedroom units average $1,110/mo (1 listing).

These listings are primarily composed of Single Familys (71%), Apartments (21%) and Multi-Family (7%). Security deposits average $953, ranging from $799 to $1,160.

13 of 14 listings (93%) are pet-friendly. Properties are managed by 2 property management companies, led by Wiechmann (12 listings). The most common lease arrangement is Rent: $959 | Application Fee: $25 | Security Deposit: $1,009 | Available Now, covering 29% of listings.

Our AI photo analysis across these listing images reveals common finishes and features. The most prevalent countertop material is Laminate Countertops (found in 79% of listings, +2% vs. average rent). Carpet is the most common flooring (79%). Refrigerator appliances appear in 86% of units. The most common architectural style is Traditional (79% of listings, avg $931/mo).

Fizbo