Sturgeon Bay Wi Rentals

819 N. 8th Avenue, #04, Sturgeon Bay, WI 54235

1 / 15

$1,825/mo

Available Now

819 N. 8th Avenue

2 bd2 ba1,103 sqft

Single Family·via SCS Swiderski·Cats allowed, Dogs allowed

View Listing

819 N. 8th Avenue , #02, Sturgeon Bay, WI 54235

1 / 15

$1,825/mo

Available Now

819 N. 8th Avenue

2 bd2 ba1,103 sqft

Single Family·via SCS Swiderski·Cats allowed, Dogs allowed

View Listing

845 N 8th Avenue , #02, Sturgeon Bay, WI 54235

1 / 15

$1,825/mo

Available Now

845 N 8th Avenue

2 bd2 ba1,103 sqft

Single Family·via SCS Swiderski·Cats allowed, Dogs allowed

View Listing

749 Delaware Street , #06, Sturgeon Bay, WI 54235

1 / 8

$1,725/mo

Available Now

749 Delaware Street

2 bd1.5 ba1,360 sqft

Single Family·via SCS Swiderski·Cats allowed, Dogs allowed

View Listing

1 / 8

$1,625/mo

Available Now

749 Delaware Street

2 bd1 ba1,040 sqft

Single Family·via SCS Swiderski·Cats allowed, Dogs allowed

View Listing

1 / 8

$1,625/mo

Available Now

750 Erie Street

2 bd1 ba1,039 sqft

Single Family·via SCS Swiderski·Cats allowed, Dogs allowed

View Listing

1 / 8

$1,625/mo

Available Now

749 Delaware Street

2 bd1 ba1,040 sqft

Single Family·via SCS Swiderski·Cats allowed, Dogs allowed

View Listing

1 / 9

$1,250/mo

Available Now

3627 Zirbel Road - 3

1 bd1 ba— sqft

Single Family·via Titan Property Management, LLC·N/A

View Listing

1 / 12

$1,474/mo

Available Now

1635 W Sycamore St

2 bd1 ba970 sqft

Apartment·via SCS Swiderski·Cats allowed, Dogs allowed

View Listing

1 / 12

$1,474/mo

Available Now

1655 Sycamore St

2 bd1 ba970 sqft

Apartment·via SCS Swiderski·Cats allowed, Dogs allowed

View Listing

1 / 13

$1,300/mo

Available Now

1635 W Sycamore St

1 bd1 ba782 sqft

Apartment·via SCS Swiderski·Cats allowed, Dogs allowed

View Listing

1 / 10

$1,300/mo

Available Now

1655 Sycamore St

1 bd1 ba686 sqft

Apartment·via SCS Swiderski·Cats allowed, Dogs allowed

View Listing

Rental Market Analysis — Sturgeon Bay, WI

Fizbo has collected 17 rental listings in Sturgeon Bay, WI. Among these, monthly rents range from $1,250 to $1,825, with an average of $1,550/mo and a median of $1,474/mo. 17 units are available for immediate move-in.

These properties range from 1 to 3 bedrooms and 1 to 2 bathrooms, averaging 1.9 beds / 1.3 baths. Living space averages 1,011 sqft (range: 686–1,360 sqft). Rent scales with size: 1-bedroom units average $1,283/mo (3 listings), 2-bedroom units average $1,609/mo (13 listings), 3-bedroom units average $1,575/mo (1 listing).

These listings are primarily composed of Apartments (53%) and Single Familys (47%). Security deposits average $1,086, ranging from $599 to $1,575.

16 of 17 listings (94%) are pet-friendly. Properties are managed by 2 property management companies, led by SCS Swiderski (16 listings). The most common lease arrangement is Rent: $1,474 | Background Check Fee: $25 | Security Deposit: $1,474 | Available 4/1/26, covering 24% of listings.

Our AI photo analysis across these listing images reveals common finishes and features. The most prevalent countertop material is Laminate Countertops (found in 47% of listings, +8% vs. average rent). LVP Flooring is the most common flooring (41%). Refrigerator appliances appear in 100% of units. The most common architectural style is Contemporary (29% of listings, avg $1,725/mo).

Sturgeon Bay Rentals

Avg Rent by Bedroom

Property Types

Lease Terms

Property Managers

Availability

Popular Features

AI Photo Analysis · Price by Finish

Countertops

Flooring

Cabinets

Appliances

Exterior

Outdoor

Garage

Home Style

Condition & Price

Rental Market Analysis — Sturgeon Bay, WI