Rentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For Rent

Rentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For Rent

Rentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For Rent

Rentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For Rent

Rentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For Rent

Rentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For Rent

Rentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For Rent

Rentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For Rent

Rentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For Rent

Rentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For Rent

Rentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For Rent

Rentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For Rent

Rentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For Rent

Rentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For Rent

Rentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For Rent

Rentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For Rent

Rentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For Rent

Rentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For Rent

Rentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For Rent

Rentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For RentRentals Whitefish Bay · WI Homes For Rent

Rentals

← Back to Fizbo

Whitefish Bay Rentals

8Rentals

$2,642Avg/Mo

$1,500Low

$3,900High

5Now

6015 N Shoreland Avenue, Whitefish Bay, WI 53217

1 / 16

$3,400/mo

Available Now

6015 N Shoreland Avenue

4 bd2 ba— sqft

Single Family·via Smart Asset Realty·Cats not allowed, Small dogs allowed

100 E Chateau Pl, Whitefish Bay, WI 53217

1 / 11

$1,500/mo

Available Now

100 E Chateau Pl

2 bd1 ba— sqft

Single Family·via Smart Asset Realty·Cats allowed, Dogs allowed

5139 N Cumberland Blvd - Middle, Whitefish Bay, WI 53217

1 / 16

$2,688/mo

Available Now

5139 N Cumberland Blvd - Middle

3 bd1.5 ba1,800 sqft

Single Family·via WH Milwaukee Property Management·Cats allowed, Small dogs allowed

5249 N Shoreland Ave, Whitefish Bay, WI 53217

1 / 10

$2,998/mo

Available Apr 10

5249 N Shoreland Ave

4 bd2.5 ba1,954 sqft

Single Family·via WH Milwaukee Property Management·Cats allowed, Dogs allowed

1 / 42

$1,625/mo

Available May 1

5200 N Diversey #201

2 bd2 ba— sqft

Apartment·via Enigma Properties·Cats allowed, Dogs not allowed

1 / 31

$1,625/mo

Available May 1

5200 N Diversey #101

2 bd2 ba— sqft

Apartment·via Rentenigma·Cats allowed, Dogs not allowed

1 / 16

$3,398/mo

Available Now

6225 N Lydell Ave

3 bd1.5 ba1,804 sqft

Apartment·via Welcome Home Milwaukee·Cats allowed, Dogs allowed

1 / 19

$3,900/mo

Available Now

5600 N Lake Dr #205

2 bd2 ba2,054 sqft

Condo·via AllSet Property Management·Cats not allowed, Small dogs allowed

$2,998

Median Rent

8

Pet Friendly

$2,783

Avg Deposit

1,903

Avg Sqft

$1,625–$3,750

Deposit Range

1,800–2,054

Sqft Range

—

Year Built

—

Avg Year

Avg Rent by Bedroom

2 bd

$2,163(4)

3 bd

$3,043(2)

4+ bd

$3,199(2)

Property Types

Single Family

450%

Apartment

338%

Condo

113%

Lease Terms

Rent: $1,625 | Application Fee: $25 | Security Deposit: $1,625 | Available 5/1/26

225%

Rent: $2,688 | Application Fee: $50 | Security Deposit: $2,688 | Available Now

113%

Rent: $2,998 | Application Fee: $50 | Security Deposit: $2,998 | Available 4/10/26

113%

Rent: $3,400 | Application Fee: $35 | Security Deposit: $3,400 | Available Now

113%

Rent: $1,500 | Available Now

113%

Rent: $3,398 | Application Fee: $50 | Security Deposit: $3,398 | Available 3/5/26

113%

Rent: $3,900 | Application Fee: $35 | Security Deposit: $3,750 | Available 3/10/26

113%

Property Managers

WH Milwaukee Property Management

225%

Smart Asset Realty

225%

Enigma Properties

113%

Welcome Home Milwaukee

113%

AllSet Property Management

113%

Rentenigma

113%

Availability

Available Now

563%

Within 30 Days

338%

30+ Days Out

00%

Popular Features

Stainless steel appliances2Gleaming hardwood floors2Central Air2Light-colored walls2

AI Photo Analysis · Price by Finish

Average rent correlated with finishes detected in listing photos

Countertops

Granite Countertops

$3,029+15%

3 (38%)

Tile Countertops

$2,249-15%

2 (25%)

Flooring

Tile Flooring

$2,647

4 (50%)

Hardwood Flooring

$3,029+15%

3 (38%)

Carpet

$2,450-7%

2 (25%)

Beige

$2,450-7%

2 (25%)

Cabinets

Shaker Cabinets

$2,094-21%

2 (25%)

Appliances

Dishwasher

$2,335-12%

4 (50%)

Microwave

$2,529-4%

3 (38%)

Stainless Steel Appliances

$2,395-9%

3 (38%)

Garbage Disposal

$1,625-38%

2 (25%)

Exterior

Shingle

$2,529-4%

3 (38%)

Brick Exterior

$2,395-9%

3 (38%)

Paved

$2,249-15%

2 (25%)

Outdoor

Mature Trees

$2,647

4 (50%)

Professional Landscaping

$2,395-9%

3 (38%)

Front Porch

$3,199+21%

2 (25%)

Privacy Fence

$3,199+21%

2 (25%)

Garage

Detached Garage

$2,647

4 (50%)

2-Car Garage

$2,843+8%

2 (25%)

Home Style

Traditional$2,647/mo

4 (50%)

Condition & Price

Updated

$2,647/mo

4 (50%)

Rental Market Analysis — Whitefish Bay, WI

Fizbo has collected 8 rental listings in Whitefish Bay, WI. Among these, monthly rents range from $1,500 to $3,900, with an average of $2,642/mo and a median of $2,998/mo. 5 units are available for immediate move-in, and 3 more become available within the next 30 days.

These properties range from 2 to 4 bedrooms and 1 to 2.5 bathrooms, averaging 2.8 beds / 1.8 baths. Living space averages 1,903 sqft (range: 1,800–2,054 sqft). Rent scales with size: 2-bedroom units average $2,163/mo (4 listings), 3-bedroom units average $3,043/mo (2 listings), 4+-bedroom units average $3,199/mo (2 listings).

These listings are primarily composed of Single Familys (50%), Apartments (38%) and Condo (13%). Security deposits average $2,783, ranging from $1,625 to $3,750.

8 of 8 listings (100%) are pet-friendly. Properties are managed by 6 property management companies, led by WH Milwaukee Property Management (2 listings). The most common lease arrangement is Rent: $1,625 | Application Fee: $25 | Security Deposit: $1,625 | Available 5/1/26, covering 25% of listings.

Our AI photo analysis across these listing images reveals common finishes and features. The most prevalent countertop material is Granite Countertops (found in 38% of listings, +15% vs. average rent). Tile Flooring is the most common flooring (50%). Dishwasher appliances appear in 50% of units. The most common architectural style is Traditional (50% of listings, avg $2,647/mo).