0%
909 Fenway Road, Saint James, NY
Stunning 2 Bedroom 2 Bath Renovated Upper Andover Model in the Highly Desired 55+ Fairfield @ St. James Gated Condominium Complex. This Andover Unit Renovation was Just Completed to Include a Remodeled Kitchen With New Stainless Steel Appliances, Recessed Lighting, Waterproof Laminate Flooring. All Doors, Hardware, Moldings, Electrical Outlets & Switches, Lighting Fixtures are New and Unit is Freshly Painted. Unit has Super Spacious Sized Rooms with Loads of Natural Light Coming in Through Updated Windows. Sliding Doors Lead to Private Covered Deck Area with Nice Wooded Views. There is a Separate Utility Room W/ Washer & Dryer, HVAC System, Hot Water Heater. HVAC System Serviced in December. Amenities Include Trips, Fitness Center, Indoor & Outdoor Swimming Pools, Billiards, Library, Tennis, Bocce, Pickleball, & Clubhouse Activities. LOW TAXES AND HOA!! COME SEE THIS GORGEOUS UNIT AND MAKE IT YOUR HOME!

Fizbo Market Record — March 29, 2026 Compared against 34 active listings in Saint James, 10,813 across New York State, and 182,059 nationwide, here is where this property stands. This condo at Fairfield at St. James features two bedrooms, two bathrooms, and 1,230 square feet of living space, built in 1987. The listing notes a recent renovation that includes a remodeled kitchen with new stainless steel appliances, recessed lighting, and waterproof laminate flooring. Additional upgrades include all-new doors, hardware, moldings, electrical outlets, switches, and lighting fixtures, as well as freshly painted walls throughout the unit. With super rooms and loads of natural light from updated windows, this property offers a comfortable living experience. Priced at $489,000, this listing ranks in the 15th percentile among active listings in Saint James, with 85% of competing properties being more expensive. However, it's worth noting that the price is actually below the city median for condos, which is also $489,000. On a statewide level, the property's price places it in the 29th percentile. When considering price per square foot, this listing ranks at the 39th percentile among city listings and the 16th percentile in terms of overall square footage. One notable aspect of this property is its relatively low price point compared to similar condos in the area. Among the six competing listings with the same bed and bath configuration, this one is priced at the 17th percentile, indicating a good value position. Additionally, the listing's features are uncommon among city listings, including a chandelier, double vanity, quartz/quartzite counters, forced air heating, and heat pump. However, it's worth mentioning that this property lacks some common features found in over 50% of city listings, such as a first-floor bedroom, first-floor full bath, and entrance foyer. These are potential objections the agent should be prepared to address during showings. On the other hand, the property's relatively low price point and good value position make it an option for buyers. With only 34 active listings in Saint James, this market is considered hot, with a median days-on-market of just 11 days. The average price per square foot in the city is $480, which suggests that prices may be trending upward. Given these market conditions, pricing strategy will be crucial to attracting potential buyers and securing a sale.
Take an interactive 3D walkthrough of this property
Property Type
Condo
Year Built
1987
Price / Sqft
$398
Days on Market
7 days
Full Baths
2
Subdivision
Fairfield at St. James
HOA Fee
$377/mo
MLS #
KEY423732998
Listing Type
Residential
Market
ONEKEY
Pending
Mar 25, 2026
District
Smithtown
Elementary
Mills Pond Elementary School
Middle
Nesaquake Middle School
High School
Smithtown High School-East
909 Fenway Road, Saint James, NY 11780 — Suffolk County County
Daniel Donato
Howard Hanna Coach

2760 Schleigel Boulevard, Amityville

147 Jackson Avenue S, Saint James

6 Ashleigh Drive, Saint James

39 Hamlet Woods Drive, Saint James

25 Pinoak Lane, Saint James
88 Astor Avenue, Saint James
506 Drew Drive, Saint James
How this home compares across city, state, and national benchmarks
Listed at $489,000, this 2-bed condo in Saint James. Compared to 4 other 2-bed homes in Saint James (averaging $518,223), this property is 6% below average. New York's median home value is $339,016, putting this listing 44% above the state benchmark. The U.S. national median home value is $334,900.
Where this listing falls among 24 homes for sale
Standout Features
Above Average
Standard
Sources: U.S. Census Bureau ACS 2023, Fizbo listing data