0%
404 S 8th Street, Cayuga, IN
Let's take a look at this inviting home with a large backyard! This 1650 square feet home features 2-3 bedrooms and one bathroom. This home has a cozy living room with a brick fireplace that leads into 2 bedrooms off of the side. Next you find a galley style kitchen with stainless steel appliances that shares an eat in dining space. Off of the dining space you find the laundry, bath and a nice sized bedroom with hardwood flooring. The home has a detached 2 car garage and is situated on 1.16 acre with a large backyard! The home has a brand new roof.

Fizbo Market Record — April 8, 2026 Compared against 182,059 active listings nationwide, 2 in Cayuga, and none in the state of Indiana, here is where this property stands. This property is a traditional-style house built in 1957, featuring 3 bedrooms, 1 bathroom, and 1,652 square feet. The listing notes that it has a brand new roof, which is a notable upgrade for a home of its age. It also mentions a brick fireplace, stainless steel appliances, hardwood flooring, and a detached 2-car garage. Priced at $160,000, this property ranks as the most expensive in Cayuga, with all other listings being more costly. However, it's worth noting that only 11% of statewide listings are priced lower than this one. In terms of price per square foot, it's also at the top end, with a ratio of 0.64x compared to the city median. This suggests that the seller may be pricing aggressively, but it's essential to consider the property's unique features and condition. One key differentiator for this listing is its age – only 0% of competing listings in Cayuga are newer than this one. Additionally, with a price/sqft percentile of 0th, it's clear that the seller is emphasizing the value per square foot. However, there may be some concerns about the property's condition and potential for renovation costs. With only two active listings in Cayuga, the competitive density is relatively low. The city average days on market is 10, but without more data, it's challenging to determine if this listing will move quickly or slowly. Given its unique features and pricing strategy, it's crucial for the agent to be prepared to address potential objections and emphasize the property's value proposition.
Property Type
Single Family
Style
Traditional
Year Built
1957
Lot Size
1.16 acres
Price / Sqft
$97
Days on Market
46 days
Full Baths
1
Subdivision
No Subdivision
MLS #
MBR22083363
Listing Type
Residential
Market
MIBOR
Pending
Mar 27, 2026
Elementary
North Vermillion Elementary School
High School
North Vermillion High School
404 S 8th Street, Cayuga, IN 47928 — Vermillion County
Lindsey Salts
Dream Home Realty Group, LLC

12008 Spring Creek Drive, Covington

2540 W Grubb Lane, Covington

12158 Spring Creek Drive, Covington

3148 S Coffing Brothers Road, Kingman
609 N Maple Street, Veedersburg
703 E Jackson Street, Attica
208 10th Street, Covington
3110 S Coffing Brothers Road, Kingman
801 Washington Street, Covington

908 S Division Street, Cayuga

219 N Wabash Street, Cayuga

612 Arrasmith Avenue, Cayuga
How this home compares across city, state, and national benchmarks
Listed at $160,000, this 3-bed house in Cayuga is 98% above the Census median home value of $81,000 for Cayuga. Compared to 2 other 3-bed homes in Cayuga (averaging $205,000), this property is 22% below average. Indiana's median home value is $139,802, putting this listing 14% above the state benchmark. The U.S. national median home value is $334,900.
Where this listing falls among 4 homes for sale
Cayuga has a population of 1,135 with a median household income of $52,393 and a homeownership rate of 75.8%. The median home value is $81,000 and the median rent is $894/mo.
Sources: U.S. Census Bureau ACS 2023, Fizbo listing data