About This Property

Set on 5.23 PRIVATE ACRES with 570' of pristine Geist Reservoir shoreline, this 21,000 sq ft gated waterfront estate redefines Midwestern luxury. A gas-lit, tree-lined drive leads to The Andretti Estate, featuring 9 bedrooms, 12 bathrooms, 7 fireplaces & surrounded by manicured lawns, wooded trails & sweeping open-water views. Inside, craftsmanship & technology merge seamlessly with integrated automation, a three-level elevator & advanced security enhancing everyday life. The main level unfolds with breathtaking vistas from every gathering space, including a fireside study that leads to the estate lounge with bar, billiards area & sitting rooms. The culinary space showcases dual kitchens: a discreet caterer's kitchen is steps away from the primary, featuring commercial-grade appliances, a 14' island, and seamless flow to a 38' heated veranda with grilling area, retractable screens, and sweeping lake views. An elegant anteroom leads to the private owner's wing with a relaxing reading room & coffee nook. A double-sided fireplace is shared with the primary bedroom, its curved walls framing lake views through a full wall of windows. A spa bath rests beneath a glass-tiled barrel ceiling, while 650 sq ft of closet space completes the suite. The upper level offers two wings, one with a loft & 2 en suite bedrooms, the other a guest wing with kitchen, living room, 2 en suite bedrooms, laundry & garage access. The resort-style walkout level presents a 15-seat bar, 700 bottle wine cellar, theater, arcade, billiards room, fitness studio, 4 bedrooms, 5 baths & 4 exterior exits. The outdoor space features a 50' gunite pool with slide, jacuzzi, waterfalls, fire features, multiple patios, a children's play cottage with HVAC & a 50' three-slip boat dock. A newer carriage house includes two 900 sq ft apartments, each with a kitchen, en suite bedroom, living room, laundry & 2-car garage. 5,500 sq ft of climate-controlled garage space with 12+ bays completes this unparalleled estate.

The Fizbit

Fizbo Market Record — March 29, 2026 Compared against 291 active listings in Fishers, 182,059 across the state of Indiana, and a total of 182,000+ nationwide, here is where this property stands. This estate is a 9-bedroom, 12-bathroom, 21,010 sqft Traditional-style house built in 1990 on 5.23 acres with 570' of Geist Reservoir shoreline. The listing notes that it features integrated automation, a three-level elevator, advanced security, and seven fireplaces. It also dual kitchens, including a discreet caterer's kitchen with commercial-grade appliances and a 14' island. Priced at $10,948,500, this property ranks as the most expensive in the city, priced above all other active listings. In fact, it is more than 23 times the median price of houses in Fishers, which stands at $484,900. The listing's price also exceeds the state median by a significant margin, with Indiana's median price sitting at $309,900. At 21,010 sqft, this property is larger than 100% of competing listings in terms of square footage, and its lot size of 5.23 acres puts it in the top percentile statewide. The estate's age, however, ranks slightly lower, with only 8% of city listings being newer. In terms of bedrooms and bathrooms, this property significantly outpaces the average for Fishers, with 2.45x more bedrooms and 3.71x more bathrooms than the typical listing in the area. With a price/sqft percentile of 100th, the agent can argue that the pricing is aggressive but justified by the estate's unique features and location. Only 0% of competing listings feature an in-law suite or private owner's wing, making these features significant differentiators for this property. However, it's worth noting that 62% of listings in Fishers include a garage, which may be a point of contention for buyers who prioritize convenience and storage space. With the market heat classified as "warm," there are currently 291 active listings competing against this one, but the agent can use the data to make a strong case for the property's value and justify its premium price.

More from Joel Woelfle