About This Property

Welcome to this charming farmhouse built in 1850 and lovingly family owned for the last 40 years, perfectly situated on 4.67 acres at the corner of Lexington Road. This property offers a rare blend of character, space, and flexibility, featuring a three-bedroom, two full bathroom main home plus an additional secondary living space on the property. Step through the front door into a welcoming living room highlighted by a beautiful original brick fireplace with a wood beam mantel. The layout flows in a functional circular design, leading into a second family room ideal for additional living or entertaining space. The kitchen offers an open concept feel into the dining area and features custom-built cabinetry, first-floor laundry, and a full bathroom conveniently located just off the kitchen. Upstairs you will find three nicely sized bedrooms, a second full bathroom, and access to a walk-up attic for additional storage or future potential. The main home has seen many important updates, including a concrete sidewalk in 2023, front porch in 2023, electric panel in 2024, roof in 2021, granite countertops in 2020, new well pump, hot water tank, pressure tank, and water softener in 2022, a new back porch in 2022, updated carpet upstairs in 2022, first-floor carpet in 2024, and a furnace installed in 2015. Adding even more value, the back of the property includes a unique secondary living space that appears to be a shed from the outside but offers a functional interior with a living room open to the kitchen, an additional living area, a bathroom, and a bedroom, with the back porch recently converted to create the bedroom. This space has its own electric box and includes a composite toilet. A detached garage and additional shed provide even more storage and utility. This is a truly special opportunity offering acreage, charm, and multiple living spaces in one property. Come take a look and experience everything this rare listing has to offer.

The Fizbit

Fizbo Market Record — April 2, 2026 Compared against 65 active listings in Alliance, 157,092 across Ohio, and 182,000+ nationwide, here is where this property stands. This farmhouse was built in 1850 and features a three-bedroom, two full bathroom main home plus an additional secondary living space on the property. The listing notes numerous updates, including custom-built cabinetry in the kitchen and a first-floor laundry area. The original brick fireplace with wood beam mantel is a notable feature of the welcoming living room. Priced at $305,000, this listing ranks as one of the most expensive in the city, priced above 89% of active inventory in Alliance. At nearly 5 acres, it's also larger than 89% of competing listings. The price-per-sqft percentile is not provided, but given its size and location, it's likely to be on the higher end. Compared to the city median price of $180,000, this listing is priced at 1.69x, which suggests a premium for its unique features and expansive lot. One notable differentiator is the property's age - built in 1850, it's one of the oldest listings in the city. Only 12% of competing listings include an in-law suite or secondary living space, making this a rare find. However, it's worth noting that 62% of listings in Alliance include a garage, and its absence may come up as an objection. With only 65 active listings in the city, competition is relatively low. The average days on market in Alliance is 41, which suggests that homes are moving at a moderate pace. Given the property's unique features and size, it's likely to attract buyers looking for a rural retreat or a historic home with character.

More from Haley Armour